Tyler J. Smith

Tyler J. Smith


Tyler has a diverse litigation practice including criminal defense, appellate advocacy, civil litigation, and employment law in state and federal courts.

Tyler has over a decade of experience in criminal defense. He is a graduate of NHTSA’s DWI Detection and Field Sobriety Testing training course. This is the exact training that law enforcement officers receive, making Tyler uniquely qualified to challenge evidence in OUI cases on behalf of his clients. Tyler was also selected by his peers in the Maine Association of Criminal Defense Attorneys to write amicus curiae briefs to the Maine Law Court in State v. Lemunier-Fitzgerald and State v. Day, each of which dealt with the constitutional issues implicated by Maine’s implied consent statute.

Tyler is also an excellent appellate attorney. He has argued dozens of cases before the Maine Supreme Judicial Court and First Circuit Court of Appeals in a wide range of practice areas, including land use, defamation, First Amendment law, employment law, and criminal defense. In law school, Tyler won first place in two national moot court competitions and first place in two school-level competitions. A few examples of Tyler’s appellate advocacy include:

  • Arguing a constitutional challenge to Maine’s 14-day quarantine to the First Circuit Court of Appeals in Bayley’s Campground v. Janet T. Mills (1st Cir. 2021). Tyler’s work in the federal district court in Bayley’s Campground resulted in one of the first federal court decisions in the country to reject the argument that the Supreme Court’s 1905 decision in Jacobson v. Massachusetts provides a relaxed constitutional standard when COVID-19 restrictions infringe on constitutional rights.
  • Successfully challenging the State of Maine’s interpretation of the term “heroin” in State v. Pinkham (Me. 2016), which ultimately prompted the Maine Legislature to pass a new law changing Maine’s criminal code.
  • Successfully arguing that a 40-year extension of an airport lease was extinguished by mortgagee’s foreclosure on the property in Littlebrook Airpark Condominium Association v. Sweet Peas, LLC (Me. 2019).
  • Vacating a six-year $3,300 per month spousal support award, and then convincing the trial court on remand to reduce the client’s spousal support obligation to just $1.00 per year.

Finally, Tyler represents and advises employers in the public and private sectors in a variety of employment areas, including compliance under the FMLA, ADA, FLSA, Title VII, Maine Human Rights Act, Maine Whistleblowers’ Protection Act, and other state and federal employment laws. Tyler is also experienced in representing employers against claims for discrimination, retaliation, harassment, defamation, wage and hour violations, and other related claims before the Maine Human Rights Commission and in state and federal trial and appellate courts.

Tyler lives in Hollis with his wife and their two children. He enjoys running, skiing, and playing guitar and mandolin.


NCDD Badge - general

Maine State Bar Association (Board of Governors, 2018-2019)
York County Bar Association
Maine Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
National College of DUI Defense
American Association of Premier DUI Attorneys
DUI Defense Lawyers Association


New Hampshire

Supreme Court of the United States
First Circuit Court of Appeals

District of Maine
District of Massachusetts
District of New Hampshire

University of Southern Maine (B.S. Computer Science, Minor in Mathematics, 2005)
Roger Williams University School of Law (J.D. 2009)


Repeated selections by Super Lawyers® New England as a “Rising Star” in the area of Litigation.

First Place  – 2009 Regent University National Moot Court Competition
Best Oralist – 2009 Regent University National Moot Court Competition
First Place – 2008 Regent University National Moot Court Competition
Fourth Best Oralist – 2008 Regent University National Moot Court Competition
Recipient – 2008 Esther Clark Scholarship
First Place – 2007 Esther Clark Moot Court Competition
First Place – 2007 Roger Williams University School of Law 1L Moot Court Competition